CBS reports: Alisa Hackett, of Osceola, Arkansas, was pulled over on State Highway 18 near Manila at about 10:45 p.m. on Aug. 1 after she was seen driving 71 mph in a 60-mph zone with the vehicle’s hazard lights on, according to an Arkansas State Police report of the incident.
When she was pulled over, Hackett told state trooper Moisses Arellano she was rushing home because her car’s window had broken, according to the police report.
Arellano noted that Hackett was not wearing her seat belt, had her license plate covered and had a cold bottle of liquor in the front seat, according to the police report. In the dashcam footage, Arellano can be heard saying, “Why do you have a Tito’s bottle, you’re not even 21?” Later in the footage, Arellano acknowledges the bottle was sealed.
Arellano described Hackett as “being difficult” when he issued her citations, according to the report. He then called another trooper who said Hackett had been pulled over for speeding “a few days earlier” and had an open alcohol container in her vehicle, but was let go with a warning.
The other trooper is heard in the footage telling Arellano, “Well, she got an attitude, take her ass to jail.”
Arellano then decided to arrest Hackett, who is 5-foot-1 and 118 pounds, and asked her to step out of the car, according to the report. After initially complying, “she began turning around and repeatedly asked what she had done,” the police report said, adding she continued to pull away from the officer and he “took her to the ground.”
“After giving multiple commands for her to roll over without compliance, I delivered one closed-fist strike to the left side of her face in an attempt to gain compliance,” Arellano wrote in the report. “After the strike, she continued resisting by pulling her wrists away and refusing to roll over.”
He pointed a stun gun at her midsection, but did not fire, and she then complied in putting her hands behind her back and she was arrested, the report said.
In the video, Hackett can be heard saying, “You cannot punch me in my face.” Arellano responds, “Who said? Who says?” and then “Who said I can’t punch you in your face?”
When she was in the back seat of the police car, Arellano can be heard saying, “If you resist, I can punch you, I can read you the policy.”
When we talk about police authority, the word “discretion” comes up constantly. Courts frequently affirm that law enforcement officers have broad discretion in how they perform their duties.
But does “discretion” mean an officer can decide how much physical force to use in any given situation—especially during non-dangerous, routine encounters?
The short answer from constitutional law is no.
While police have significant cognitive and decision-making discretion (deciding whether to pull someone over, write a citation, or make an arrest), their authority to apply physical force is strictly governed by the Fourth Amendment. Physical force is not a discretionary choice; it is subject to an objective standard of law.
Here is how the U.S. Supreme Court distinguishes between the two.
1. Cognitive & Enforcement Discretion: Broad Latitude
Enforcement discretion refers to the choices officers make about when and how to enforce the law. The Supreme Court gives police wide latitude in this area.
-
Town of Castle Rock v. Gonzales (2005)
-
The Rule: Law enforcement has deep-rooted, traditional discretion in deciding whether and when to enforce mandates.
-
The Takeaway: Individuals generally do not have a constitutionally protected right to force police to make an arrest or enforce a civil order, maintaining that enforcement decisions remain inherently discretionary.
-
-
Atwater v. City of Lago Vista (2001)
-
The Rule: Officers have the discretionary authority to make a warrantless custodial arrest for minor, fine-only offenses (like a seatbelt violation).
-
The Takeaway: While the decision to execute an arrest falls under officer discretion, the Court made clear that the manner of the seizure and any physical force used during it remain subject to strict constitutional limits.
-
2. Physical Force: Bound by “Objective Reasonableness”
When an encounter shifts from decision-making to physical contact, officer discretion stops and the Fourth Amendment takes over. The Supreme Court has repeatedly established that officers do not have discretionary authority to use unnecessary physical force.
-
Graham v. Connor (1989)
-
The Rule: The landmark decision establishing that all claims of excessive physical force must be judged by “objective reasonableness”—not an officer’s personal discretion or subjective intent.
-
The Three-Prong Test: To determine if force is reasonable, courts evaluate:
-
The severity of the alleged crime.
-
Whether the suspect poses an immediate threat to safety.
-
Whether the suspect is actively resisting or attempting to flee.
-
-
Application: In a non-dangerous encounter where an individual poses no threat and isn’t resisting, applying physical force fails the objective reasonableness test.
-
-
Tennessee v. Garner (1985)
-
The Rule: Completely eliminated officer discretion regarding the use of lethal physical force against non-dangerous fleeing suspects.
-
Application: Deadly force cannot be used simply to prevent escape unless the officer has probable cause to believe the suspect poses a significant threat of death or serious injury to others.
-
-
Barnes v. Felix (2025)
-
The Rule: Lower courts cannot isolate a single “moment of threat” to justify physical force; they must evaluate the totality of the circumstances.
-
Application: The Court affirmed that officers cannot claim immunity for physical force by ignoring their own prior actions that unnecessarily escalated a non-dangerous stop into a violent encounter.
-
EARN’s Stance
Discretion governs the decision to act; the Fourth Amendment governs the use of force.
While the law grants officers the cognitive space to navigate complex situations, it leaves no room for discretionary force when there is no objective threat.
| Category | Legal Standard | Scope of Discretion |
| Cognitive / Decision-Making | Executive Authority & Probable Cause | Broad: Officers choose whether to warn, cite, investigate, or arrest. |
| Physical Force | Fourth Amendment “Objective Reasonableness” | Strictly Limited: Must be proportional to the threat. Zero discretion to use force in compliant, non-dangerous settings. |


